Oct 27, 2013; Minneapolis, MN, USA; Minnesota Vikings quarterback Josh Freeman (12) sits by the other quarterbacks during the fourth quarter against the Green Bay Packers at Mall of America Field at H.H.H. Metrodome. The Packers defeated the Vikings 44-31. Mandatory Credit: Brace Hemmelgarn-USA TODAY Sports

Does Anyone Still Believe the Vikings Are "Evaluating" Josh Freeman?


The season isn’t over and I suppose there’s still a chance Josh Freeman could see action on the field for the Vikings, but really, does it even matter anymore? What is there left for us to learn about Freeman that we don’t already know from the way things have transpired? If Freeman had anything at all, would he not already be out there?

I admit, I was on board with the whole Freeman experiment at first. I bought the line of reasoning that the Vikings had nothing to lose by bringing Freeman in and seeing what he could do. What the heck? The season is in the crapper anyway. Give Freeman a shot.

Rick Spielman laid it all out pretty plainly: signing Freeman wasn’t so much about the present as the future. “In this scenario you’ve just got to take your shot. You have the opportunity to keep a player around for a few months and to learn a lot about him, whether he plays very much or not,” Spielman said. “When does the opportunity present itself that you don’t have to spend a high draft choice or a big contract to acquire a young quarterback with lots of starting experience?”

I swallowed that stuff hook, line and sinker, as did a lot of other people. It should have become pretty obvious right away that Spielman was lying through his teeth.

Freeman’s acquisition was never about evaluating him for next season. That was just a cute way to sell what looked on the surface like a desperation move from a franchise that felt its season slipping away.

There was plenty of evidence that Spielman wanted immediate results from Freeman despite all his talk about evaluating him for next year. The way Freeman was immediately rushed into action on the field. Why do that if you don’t care about the short-term?

It’s right there in Spielman’s own statements. “You have the opportunity to keep a player around for a few months and learn a lot about him, whether he plays very much or not.”

But if you’re not concerned about seeing him on the field, why force him out there before he’s ready? Why take the risk of him embarrassing himself and you?

It should have been clear why the decision was made to hurriedly prepare Freeman and stick him into battle. It was because Spielman and Co. have no faith in Christian Ponder or Matt Cassel and knew they had no chance of salvaging the season with either of those quarterbacks at the helm.

Spielman wanted us to believe that acquiring Freeman was an opportunistic move made with an eye toward the future, but that was a flat-out load of malarkey. In fact it was a panic move. It was a move no less desperate than Brad Childress’ decision to trade a third round pick to New England for Randy Moss.

The Vikings were hoping for a quick fix with Freeman, but not wanting to look like panic monkeys, they sold it as something they were doing for the future. After seeing Freeman on the field they realized their blunder and decided to stash Freeman away for the rest of the season with the cover story of “evaluating” him in practice.

This is my belief now, after so many weeks of Freeman being totally out of the mix at QB. If you really and truly thought Freeman was worth evaluating, you would at least have him as the #2 behind Christian Ponder, so that if the game got out of hand or Ponder got injured, you could put Freeman in and get a look. Evaluating a guy in practice is fine, but nothing compares to live game action.

Freeman’s weekly status as the #3 QB speaks volumes. The Vikings think he is terrible. They think it was a horrible decision to sign him in the first place. This is the only conclusion we can reach.

Spielman knows he messed up thinking this guy could save their season, but rather than tacitly admit the blunder by outright releasing the QB, he will keep Freeman stashed away until the end of the year. Then Freeman will quietly walk away, and the Vikings will move on.

In the meantime, the Vikings will keep floating out the same baloney about evaluating Freeman. I bought it initially but I’m not buying it anymore. The Freeman signing was a horrific miscalculation by Rick Spielman, one borne not out of big-picture-minded calculation but absolute pants-soiling panic.

Spielman’s job must be in greater jeopardy than we guessed for him to respond that way to a bad start. I once thought for sure Spielman would be back in 2014, but now I’m not convinced. I think there’s a chance Spielman will be out with Leslie Frazier and everyone else. Maybe he and Josh Freeman can car pool to the airport.

Like The Viking Age on Facebook.
Follow TVA on Twitter.
Subsribe to the Fansided Daily Newsletter. Sports news all up in your inbox.

Next Vikings Game View full schedule »
Thursday, Aug 2828 Aug7:00at Tennessee TitansBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: Josh Freeman Minnesota Vikings

  • Daniel Laxen

    What are you talking about? The Vikings indeed signed Freeman hoping he would pull them together and give them a viable option at the QB position. The way the season is transpiring the final wild card could well be around a.500 ball club? It’s a long season and the risk was worth the reward had it paid dividends.
    What it really did was show that there are more issues than answers. When Freeman failed after being in the system for less than 2 weeks was tell everyone in Minnesota that what they had was an abortion of a team. The players that had bought in were now questioning everything they were told. The veterans savvy enough to know saw through the veil of lies that Spielman and the coaching staff had put out there. They questioned the leadership from GM all the way down, on this team since that decision and ultimate failure.
    I’m sure that Freeman will see action this year. After all the season is finite, but the franchise will move on beyond this awful year…I don’t give Spielman or any coach a pass here, either. They deserve what they get. Spielman is the man at fault. He usurped Frazier’s authority and now he’s lost any shred of respect that he had prior. after all Frazier gave Ponder his word about the QB position. When Freeman failed he was forced to go back to Ponder.
    What’s looking more and more evident is that the system is what’s wrong in Minnesota. A system that Rick Spielman and Leslie Frazier threw out there, for all Viking fans to swallow. Ponder isn’t bereft of blame, either. he has been as inconsistent as any QB over the last 3 years. talented QBs have enough leadership ability to adjust on the fly. Ponder hasn’t done that and the Vikings are a laughing stock because of it.
    Freeman will play again for the Vikings this season. Another bad performance is all the requirement for that, and it’s coming!

  • Lisa Guevara

    I think we will see Freeman soon. Frazier has the conviction of a captain going down with the ship (with Ponder). I think Spielman will make a Hail Mary pass soon and switch to Freeman to hopefully save his job. Still hope the owner will make a clean sweep of management and rebuild the Vikings.

    • Daniel Laxen

      Couldn’t agree more! Spielman should be the 1st one on the bus out of town!

  • Danny

    Josh Freeman was an average quarterback at best from the start. His first offensive coach was fired before the season started because he said that Freeman wasn’t good enough to be the starter. He never was and never will be. If NFL coaches can’t see that they should watch film of him or find another job!