Vikings 12, Lions 10

Here was the plan as I conceived it in my brain:  Vikings come out strong against the Lions, run their offense efficiently and finish off drives with points, avoid turnovers and other mistakes, play solid defense, run away in the second half to finish with a convincing win of the 30-10 variety.  As we all know by know, this did not happen.  The Vikings never did take control of this game – in fact, neither team felt like it ever had control.  The offense was anything but efficient – instead it sputtered and staggered.  Turnovers?  Two costly Adrian Peterson fumbles and a bad interception by Gus Frerotte.  Other mistakes?  7 penalties, three by Ryan Cook; not to mention the offensive line breakdowns leading to a flurry of sacks.  The solid defense part was the only thing that came true.  And even the defense had its breakdowns – it allowed a 50 yard run to Kevin Smith and some big plays by Calvin Johnson.  Thankfully, we were playing the Detroit Lions.  A real football team would’ve stomped us into the dirt the way we played yesterday.  Hell, even the Lions, with Jon Kitna in the game instead of Dan Orlovsky, probably would’ve beaten us.  Unless, of course, we were bailed out by the refs.  Which we were.

A Win’s a Win?

Brad Childress and his players have already unleashed the chorus for the week:  A win’s a win.  Obviously they don’t pay any attention to the fans or the TV and radio commentators who continue criticizing this team regardless of their record.  3-3 is not 3-3 – not when two of your wins were gift-wrapped by the officials.  Not when your offense still looks like a slow-motion trainwreck 75% of the time.  Not when your game-plan fails to make use of perhaps the single most dynamic offensive player in the league.  Not when you persist in marching Ryan Cook out to play right tackle when anyone with two eyes and a fundamental knowledge of football can see he is overmatched.

Every week Brad Childress says the same thing:  “There are things we have to clean up.”  But another game comes along and these things are still not cleaned up.  And this is why people don’t believe a win is a win; this is why they chant “Fire Childress” at the games and bash him when they call into radio shows and post on message boards.  This team, they realize, is not good enough to really go anywhere.  Not the way they play.  Not the way they shoot themselves in the foot.  We might’ve believed a little more had the team shown signs of cleaning those things up against Detroit, but it was the same old jive:  Slow start.  God awful offense.  Self-inflicted wounds.  Undeserved victory.

Blame the Players

I’m not, for the time being, going to lend my voice to the “Fire Childress” cries.  Everything that can be said about Childress has been said.  For now I’m going to turn my attention to the players, who deserve at least 75% of the criticism for the crap that went down against Detroit.  I’ve already said my piece about Ryan Cook:  He’s terrible and needs to be replaced.  Artis Hicks should be the starter at right tackle, if not in the next game, then coming out of the bye week.  If Cook is allowed to keep whiffing on pass rushers, Gus Frerotte will end up broken in pieces and Tarvaris Jackson will be back as quarterback.  On the whole, I’d say our offensive line has not been doing the job.  They haven’t been pass protecting well, which has really hurt us in the redzone where the quarterback always needs to hold onto the ball longer to allow receivers to work open, and they haven’t been run blocking with particular effectiveness either.  Bryant McKinnie, Steve Hutchinson and Matt Birk do not constitute the best left-side in football – they are, at their best, adequate.  Even Mike Morris, a guy who goes out of his way to defend his buddies along the line, says they’re not getting off the ball the same way they were last year when they helped Adrian Peterson to a monster rookie season.  And forget about the Tony Richardson effect.  His lead-blocking was not all that important to Peterson’s success last year.  Many of Peterson’s biggest runs came off single-back formations.  In fact, you could argue that the Vikings, on the whole, employ a lead blocker too often.

And speaking of Adrian Peterson…we all go out of our way to give AD a break, but this week he doesn’t deserve one.  His two fumbles were a major part of why this team was unable to score.  I love effort and trying to fight for extra yards as much as the next person, but Peterson needs to learn to wrap up the ball and needs to learn to just go down.  An extra half-yard doesn’t mean anything if you then cough up the ball and the other team gets it.  His first fumble came when the team was in field goal range, so that’s at least 3 points off the board, and his second came when the offense was desperate to establish itself late.  His fumbles were even more killer than Ryan Cook’s badly-timed holding penalties and whiff-blocks.  That being said, he still managed 111 yards on 25 carries.

The Calls

When is a fumble not a fumble?  When a guy is clearly on the ground and the defensive player rips it out.  However, in the bizarro universe the Vikings sometimes call home, a fumble that isn’t a fumble can indeed be a fumble.  Such was the case yesterday when the refs reviewed Calvin Johnson’s non-fumble, which they had already called a fumble, and decided it was in fact a fumble.  This was a huge play for the Vikings, who at that point were looking at the Lions going in for a score that would’ve given them control of the game and probably the win.  The refs would give the Vikes a second gift at the end of the game when they called Leigh Bodden for interfering with Aundrae Allison – a play that led to the game-winning field goal.  That’s two straight games the Vikings might’ve lost but for an interference call (though the one in the Saints game was more legit).  A win’s a win though right?

Yeah – until those breaks stop going your way.  Which they will inevitably do.  Probably next week against the Bears, a team good enough on offense and defense to take advantage of Purple miscues and make life miserable for us.  I’ll say it again – we’re lucky it was the Lions.


The Lions defense was supposed to stink, but I thought it played pretty well.  Their pass rush gave us fits – not a shock considering the softness of our offensive line – and their guys made plays all over the field.  Special kudos to Leigh Bodden, a guy I wouldn’t mind having in place of Cedric Griffin.  Solid trade by the Lions to get that guy in there.

Speaking of defensive stand-outs…did anyone stand out more than Kevin Williams?  What a gigantic game for K-Will.  4 sacks, raising his season total to 6 (twice his total from last year).  Jared Allen may not be racking up the big numbers himself, but his presence is opening things up for K-Will who is taking advantage.  Antoine Winfield was defensive player of the week last week, and Williams may very well make it two such honors in a row for the Vikings.  The defense is clearly not the problem (shaky downfield coverage and loss of E.J. Henderson notwithstanding).

Another guy who deserves kudos is Bernard Berrian.  The big free-agent signee got heat when his season started slowly, but now he’s developed into a true offensive weapon.  He scored the team’s only TD yesterday on a slant thrown from four-wide (a formation we really need to look at using more often).  He finished with 5 catches for 131 yards, his second straight 100+ yard game and his fourth straight 70+ yard performance.  His season stats:  22 catches, 436 yards, 2 TDs.  That projects out to around 60 catches for 1162 yards, but only 5 TDs.  He’s clearly the best receiver we’ve had since Randy Moss – maybe not a great accomplishment when you consider the kind of crap that’s floated through here since then (Travis Taylor, Marcus Robinson, Troy Williamson, etc.,)

Next Vikings Game View full schedule »
Sunday, Sep 77 Sep12:00at St. Louis RamsBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: Adrian Peterson Antoine Winfield Artis Hicks Aundrae Allison Bernard Berrian Brad Childress Bryant Mckinnie Calvin Johnson Cedric Griffin Dan Orlovsky Detroit Lions E.j. Henderson Gus Frerotte Jared Allen Jon Kitna Kevin Smith Kevin Williams Leigh Bodden Marcus Robinson Matt Birk Mike Morris Minnesota Vikings New Orleans Saints Randy Moss Ryan Cook Steve Huthinson Tarvaris Jackson Tony Richardson Travis Taylor Troy Williamson

  • AustinVike

    Seriously, I know we won and everything, and that I should probably be happier…but.
    The negatives (because I’m in a crap mood):

    We gave up FIVE sacks to one of the worst defenses in the league.
    We outscored Detroit by 2 measly points (although we were favored to win by 14+ points).
    Peterson fumbled 3 times, twice in the red zone, twice recovered by Detroit. Not good at all.
    If Longwell hadn’t made the winning FG, we would’ve LOST to the Detroit (frickin) Lions!
    Also safe to assume if Longwell had missed that FG, Childress would be trying out kickers this week…
    The Vikings failed to score on their first 8 drives of the game. Unacceptable and unbelievable.

    The (few) positives:

    Kevin Williams recorded 4 sacks…by…him…self. He deserves the “Antoine Winfield Defensive Terrorizer of the Week” trophy, in my opinion.
    Jared Allen also recorded 1 sack (about time!) and also made the difference while pursuing Orlovsky, forcing him to commit a safety, almost unknowingly (hilariously).
    Berrian is finally being put to good use, making plays, running like the wind.
    Frerotte threw for 301 yds (although finished with 296 yds for the day). Those are Jay Cutler numbers (which is good – or good enough at least).

    A few extra observations.
    The Vikings need to start utilizing the passing game much more, now that Frerotte has proven he can throw the ball safely to players on his own team. Frerotte has also proven that he can take some pretty severe punishment, and remain intact – which is important because it shows that he can be a consistent leader with alot of toughness – something a certain other Vikings QB lacks.
    I also think if the Vikings can be more consistent on at least trying some more 4WR or even some 5WR formations, they could really mess with the opposing teams’ gameplan. It seems fairly obvious that opposing teams are basing their game plans around stopping Adrian Peterson, containing the run, and just defending a shorter field (because “the Vikings cannot throw the ball” – I’ve heard it a million times from just about every Packer fan).
    Why not stretch an opposing defense with a good 4WR formation on a second down (when they fully expect a nice, safe, run play)?
    This is why I have a general problem with Childress. His play calling is too predictable, and he’s not utilizing the talent that the Vikings have. Instead he’s playing it safe, handing the ball to Adrian, throwing a TE slant in there once in a while, and calling it good enough to get into FG range.
    It’s enough to drive a Vikings fan crazy!
    Additionally: Brad Childress’s (ESPN) approval rating is currently 15%.

  • jeege

    Way to give the players the correct amount of disdain this week. I, like many thousands of others Im sure, stared in disbelief as that second ball popped out of AD’s hands this week. Miscue after miscue on offense had me in tatters for about, oh, ninety five percent of this game.

    But to be sure, WHAT a performance from our defense. I haven’t peaked at the stat line yet, but something like 5 sacks and constant pressure was exactly the cure for what ails us on D. I don’t think that Smith run was worth anything but a missed tackle. We have our D to thank for that win.

    If the offense could play with an ounce as much intensity as I see from the D every single play…wow…we would certainly reach the high expectations everyone has for this team.

    What a shame, however, if the offense wastes what could very well be a Hall-of-Fame type lineup on the other side of the ball. Did you see Kevin Williams?!? Oh my gosh, he was on another level yesterday. He exists in a different realm.

    I need to see AD get that look in his eyes too. THEN we’d see them reel off some convincing wins. Starting next week against those damn Bears.

    But your right, if we played anyone but the Lions this week…I’m not sure the superstar D we have would have been enough.

  • AustinVike

    Another interesting stat, brought to us by Dave Campbell, Associated Press:

    Berrian and Wade got open more than they did in any of the first five games, enough to give Gus Frerotte – who went 18-for-33 with one interception – 296 yards passing. That’s the highest total by a quarterback in 38 games since Childress took over.

    296 yards passing in one game is the highest total by a Vikings QB since Childress took over.

    There are teams in this sport that pass for more than 300 almost every week.

    Just saying…