The Minnesota Vikings spent last week describing safety as one of their deepest positions. Then they brought Harrison Smith back on a substantial one-year contract. Those two decisions don’t fit together as neatly as the team might prefer.
General manager Nolan Teasley praised a group featuring Josh Metellus, Jay Ward, Theo Jackson, Jakobe Thomas and Jacob Thomas after final cuts. Both rookies made the initial 53-man roster, apparently validating Minnesota’s summer evaluation.
Signing Smith doesn’t mean the Vikings suddenly dislike those players. It does suggest their confidence had a limit, especially after Jamal Adams suffered a season-ending quadriceps injury and the two rookies dealt with injuries during camp.
Harrison Smith’s return puts a firm ceiling on Minnesota Vikings' trust in its rookies
Smith, 37, missed the entire offseason program while considering retirement. Minnesota nevertheless reportedly committed $12.25 million to him, with incentives that could push the deal to $16.25 million. That’s not the contract of an emergency backup or a mentor for the young guys.
The Vikings expect Smith to play.
That expectation cuts directly into the opportunities available for Jakobe Thomas and Jacob Thomas. Jakobe, a third-round pick, already lost valuable summer work to a back injury. Jacob was one of Minnesota’s best preseason stories, earning his roster spot after arriving as an undrafted free agent.
Neither rookie can match Smith’s command of Brian Flores’ defense. Smith can disguise coverage, rotate after the snap, pressure from multiple alignments and handle communication responsibilities. Minnesota’s young safeties may eventually offer some of that versatility, but that doesn’t help against Green Bay in Week 1.
The size of Smith’s deal also makes it difficult to imagine a limited ceremonial role. Minnesota is paying for a meaningful contributor, presumably alongside Metellus, while Ward and Jackson compete for the remaining defensive work.
That doesn’t make keeping both rookies a mistake. Developing the Thomas rookies behind Smith is more sensible than forcing either of them into complicated assignments before they're ready. Their special-teams value can also preserve roster spots while Flores works them into smaller defensive packages.
But the reunion changes the evaluation. Minnesota may believe it has good young safeties, but the money it shelled out says it doesn't quite trust the group enough -- yet -- to enter the season without Smith.
One player must also leave the full roster when the transaction is completed, creating a less pleasant side to the winners and losers from Smith’s return. If that casualty comes from the safety room, Minnesota’s earlier show of confidence will have lasted roughly one week.
Add us as a preferred source on Google