Skip to main content

Vikings' first loss just changed what Jonathan Taylor should cost them

ByAllison Koehler
Indianapolis Colts running back Jonathan Taylor
Indianapolis Colts running back Jonathan Taylor | David Berding/GettyImages

The Minnesota Vikings’ 19-15 loss to the Detroit Lions should make them more willing to pay for Jonathan Taylor, but it still shouldn’t pry a first-round pick out of Nolan Teasley’s hands.

Minnesota rushed for 81 yards Sunday, and 35 came from Kyler Murray. Aaron Jones and Jordan Mason combined for 42 yards on 13 carries, another rough offensive showing after Minnesota’s ongoing offensive problems had already become difficult to dismiss at 6-0.

Taylor wouldn’t have magically turned every failed block into five yards. He would, however, give Kevin O’Connell a runner who can create more when blocking is merely adequate. For an offense asking Murray to stabilize the quarterback position while Justin Jefferson and Jordan Addison draw defensive attention outside, that matters.

Minnesota Vikings should raise their Jonathan Taylor offer after Detroit

Their first loss of the season moved the acceptable price upward because the Vikings finally saw the downside of their current setup against another NFC North contender.

Jones has been managing a knee issue, while Mason had already emerged as Minnesota’s workhorse before Detroit held him to 20 yards on eight attempts. Neither result means those backs suddenly became liabilities. It shows how thin the margin gets when O’Connell can’t reliably manufacture favorable second and third downs on the ground.

My line is pretty simple. A first-round pick remains a no. A second deserves a serious discussion. A second plus a late-round pick gets painful enough that Minnesota should hesitate, but not automatically walk away. A third would be an immediate yes.

Indianapolis is now open to moving Taylor, with Minnesota among the teams that have shown interest, according to NFL Network trade reporting.

A first is still too rich because Minnesota may need that asset for a quarterback, premium offensive lineman, pass rusher, or another expensive position next spring. Running backs can alter games. First-round picks can alter roster construction for five years.

Minnesota also owns nine selections in the 2027 draft, including its first, second, and two thirds, which gives Teasley room to be aggressive without emptying the cupboard. The urgency is legitimate because Minnesota’s current contention window includes a Brian Flores defense playing at a championship level and an offense that keeps asking that defense to survive one more stalled possession.

Detroit didn’t prove the Vikings need Taylor at any cost. It showed exactly why paying a little more than Minnesota preferred last week could make sense now. If Indianapolis gets down to a second-rounder, Teasley should be deep in the conversation. If the Colts insist on Minnesota’s first, they can keep taking calls.

Add us as a preferred source on Google